WASHINGTON — In a letter sent
today, a diverse group of over thirty recording artists urged FCC Chairman
Michael Powell to grant Congress and the public a full opportunity to
review any proposed changes of media ownership rules before they are enacted.
The letter cites four published reports containing empirical evidence
that media ownership rules are necessary. The letter also suggests there
is overwhelming proof that the public wants limits held in place. Empirical
evidence is the standard the US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit requires
the FCC to meet in showing the existing rules are necessary.
I am pleased to join dozens of my fellow musicians who are calling
for a more open policy process, said Eagles songwriter and recording
artist Don Henley. As artists, we recognize the important role that
radio and other media play in the vitality of the American culture. It
is outrageous that many citizens are not even aware these changes are
being debated. To a large extent, this is because the FCC leadership has
not fully engaged the public. But what frightens me more is the complete
absence of any network coverage of this issue. The broadcast interests
who clearly stand to benefit from further consolidation have seemingly
absolved themselves of their responsibility to cover this proceeding as
a news story. If this is the sort of biased coverage we get now, I cant
imagine what will pass as journalism in the next phase of our increasingly
consolidated media future.
The letter cites a study by
the Future of Music Coalition, which provides compelling evidence that
radio consolidation has resulted in reduced marketplace competition, reduced
programming diversity and the homogenization of playlists, reduced public
access to the airwaves for local programming, and reduced public satisfaction
with listening options.
There are clear lessons from the dramatic consolidation of ownership
in the radio industry following the Telecommunications Act of 1996 and
how it has impacted the historic goals of localism, competition and diversity.
It is less clear whether all the FCC Commissioners are interested in exploring
what those lessons are, said Ann Chaitovitz, Director of Sound Recordings
at The American Federation of Television and Radio Artists (AFTRA).
The letter also cites a December 2002 Center for Economic and Policy
Research and Department for Professional Employees/AFL-CIO critique
of twelve studies commissioned by the FCC to examine media ownership
issues. The report raised serious questions about the impact of concentration
on diversity of news and entertainment and indicated that there is little
basis for believing that substitution between types of media will offset
any negative effects from concentration in a specific medium.
The media rules under debate at the FCC determine how citizens
receive their news, information and entertainment, said Michael
Bracy, Director of Government Relations, Future of Music Coalition. Its
critical for the continued health of our democracy that there be full
public debate about the potential impact of these rules.
In the letter, the artists also mention the lack of participation by
Chairman Powell and Commissioners Abernathy and Martin in field hearings
designed to increase public participation and comments on proposed rule
changes. I have attended field hearings in New York, Richmond, Durham,
and Seattle, and I have heard testimony from hundreds of citizens who
are concerned about the direction the FCC is heading, said Jenny
Toomey, Executive Director, Future of Music Coalition. I have read
through thousands of public comments in the FCC docket. The overwhelming
majority of those who have come forward urge Chairman Powell to maintain
the existing cross ownership caps. It is abundantly clear that the only
supporters of this fast-track deregulation are the very corporations who
will benefit financially from further consolidation. If the FCC has any
clear mandate it is to protect the public interest from these private interests.
Signing on to the letter were: Carmine Appice, Jackson Browne, Jimmy
Buffett, David Crosby, Neil Diamond, John Doe, Don Henley, Indigo Girls
(Amy Ray and Emily Saliers), Billy Joel, Lenny Kaye, Toby Keith, Ian MacKaye,
Ray Manzarek, Ellis L. Marsalis, Jr., Mya, Tim McGraw, Paul D. Miller,
Sam Moore, Thurston Moore, Stevie Nicks, Joan Osborne, Van Dyke Parks,
Pearl Jam, Sandy Pearlman, Tom Petty, Bonnie Raitt, Kevin Richardson,
Patti Smith, Stephan Smith, Michael Stipe, Tom Waits, Jennifer Warnes,
Saul Williams, and Nancy Wilson.
PDF of this
press release | Letter