|
|
|
|
Additional Information about the Analysis of the FCC
Docket 02-277
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
Q: How did you review the comments?
A: The FCC has created an Electronic Comment Filing System (EFCS) on their
website where citizens, organizations and corporations are able to submit
comments electronically, either as an email or a PDF. The comments are
then made instantly available for public review at http://gullfoss2.fcc.gov/prod/ecfs/comsrch_v2.cgi
.
Q: How many comments were filed on this proceeding?
A: This is a difficult number to pin down, but here is our approximation.
As of last Friday, May 8, there were 5500 comments available for review
on the FCCs website. However, this number is deceiving as there
were about 4500 comments filed within the DC portion of the docket that
were collections of letters that the FCC received via postal mail and
email and scanned to create multi-page PDFs. Therefore there were many
entries in the DC docket that said 104 citizen letters or
456 citizen letters. We went through all of these as well
and all 4500 citizen comments were against the rule changes.
In addition, the FCC has a CD ROM with 12,011 other comments received
via postal mail, email or fax that have been scanned but not posted on
the website. We have a copy of this CD ROM but have not had the time or
volunteer resources to review it.
Finally, the FCCs Resource Center has indicated that there are more
comments that have arrived via postal mail, email or fax that have yet
to be scanned or processed.
Q: What did the comments say?
A: For the purposes of our project, we analyzed what was available to
us via the FCCs website. The grand total of comments reviewed was
9360. The summary of this review is:
|
|
|
Total AGAINST |
Unknown/Other |
Total FOR |
|||
|
|
|
citizen |
corp/org |
citizen |
corp/prg |
citizen |
corp/org |
|
Total comments |
9360 |
9065 |
99 |
54 |
85 |
11 |
46 |
Q: What corporations and organizations are FOR the rule changes?
A: Along with the 11 citizen comments, the following companies, organizations
and government officials filed comments supporting rule changes:
|
1 |
Alaska Broadcasting Company |
DC |
|
2 |
Bear Stearns (Victor Miller) |
DC/NY |
|
3 |
Belo Corp. (Wiley Rein & Fielding) |
DC/TX |
|
4 |
Block Communications Inc. |
DC |
|
5 |
Bonneville International Corporation |
DC |
|
6 |
Caribbean Int'l News Corp. (Maureen Jeffreys, Arnold |
DC |
|
7 |
Clear Channel Communications (Christopher Robbins/E |
DC/TX |
|
8 |
Cosmos Broadcasting Corp. |
DC |
|
9 |
Disney/ABC (Jared Sher, Skadden Arps/Susan Fox) |
DC |
|
10 |
Dispatch Broadcasting Group (R. Clark Wadlow, Sidley |
DC |
|
11 |
Economists Inc. (Bruce Owen) |
DC |
|
12 |
Emmis Communications Corp. (John Fiorini, Wiley Rein |
DC |
|
13 |
Fox/News Corp. (Brian Weimer, Skadden Arps) |
DC |
|
14 |
Gannett Co. (Kathleen Kirby, Wiley Rein & Fielding) |
DC |
|
15 |
Grant Communications (Kenneth Satten, Wilkinson Bark |
DC |
|
16 |
Gray Television (Robert Beizer) |
DC |
|
17 |
Hearst Corp. (Jennifer Blum, Drinker Biddle & Reath) |
DC |
|
18 |
Hearst-Argyle |
NC |
|
19 |
Illinois Broadcasters Association |
IL |
|
20 |
Lockwood |
NC |
|
21 |
Media General (John Feore/M. Anne Swanson, Dow Loh |
DC |
|
22 |
Morris Communications Corp. (James Bayes, Wiley Rei |
DC |
|
23 |
NABET-CWA (Dan Mahoney/Leroy Watson) |
DC |
|
24 |
NBC (Jay Ireland) |
DC |
|
25 |
NBC/Telemundo (F.William LeBeau) |
DC |
|
26 |
Newspaper Ass'n of America (Martha Heller, Wiley Rie |
DC |
|
27 |
Nexstar (Elizabeth Hammond/Howard Liberman, Drinke |
DC |
|
28 |
Paxson |
FL |
|
29 |
Quincy Newspapers |
DC |
|
30 |
Representative "Billy" Tauzin (Congress) |
DC |
|
31 |
Representative Michael Oxley (Congress) |
DC |
|
32 |
Representative Rick Boucher (Congress) |
DC |
|
33 |
Richard Wiley, Wiley Rein & Fielding |
DC |
|
34 |
Sinclair Broadcasting Group (Kathryn Schmeltzer, Sha |
DC |
|
35 |
The National Grange (Leroy Watson) |
DC |
|
36 |
Tribune Company |
DC |
|
37 |
Univision Communications Inc (Scott Flick, Shaw Pittm |
DC |
|
38 |
Verizon |
VA |
|
39 |
Viacom (Anne Lucey) |
DC |
|
40 |
Westwind |
NC |
Q: And what companies and organizations filed comments OPPOSING the rule
changes?
|
1 |
ACTION COALITION FOR MEDIA EDUCATION (part of Children Now filing) |
CA |
|
2 |
AFTRA |
NY |
|
3 |
Alliance for a Media Literate America |
NY |
|
4 |
Alliance for Community Media |
DC |
|
5 |
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF CHILD AND ADOLESCENT PSYCHIATRY (part of Children Now filin |
CA |
|
6 |
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS (part of Children Now filing) |
CA |
|
7 |
American Cable Association |
IL |
|
8 |
AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION (part of Children Now filing) |
CA |
|
9 |
American Women in Radio & Television |
VA |
|
10 |
Amherst Alliance |
RI |
|
11 |
Arso Radio Corp |
FL |
|
12 |
Association of Micro-Power Broadcasters |
CA |
|
13 |
Attorney General for the State of Washington |
WA |
|
14 |
Attorney General of the State of Connecticut |
CT |
|
15 |
Black Citizens for a Fair Media |
DC |
|
16 |
Buckley Broadcasting Corporation |
CT |
|
17 |
BUNGALOW 78 ENTERTAINMENT (part of Writers Guild West filing) |
CA |
|
18 |
Capitol Broadcasting Co |
VA |
|
19 |
Caucus for Television Producers, Writers and Directors |
DC |
|
20 |
Center for Digital Democracy |
DC |
|
21 |
CENTER FOR MEDIA EDUCATION (part of Children Now filing) |
CA |
|
22 |
Center for the Creative Community |
VA |
|
23 |
CHILDREN NOW |
CA |
|
24 |
Citizen Action |
IL |
|
25 |
Civil Rights Forum |
DC |
|
26 |
Coalition for a democratic Pacifica |
NY |
|
27 |
Coalition for Program Diversity |
DC |
|
28 |
Communications Science and Technologies |
NY |
|
29 |
Communications Workers of America |
DC |
|
30 |
Consumer Federation of America |
DC |
|
31 |
Department for Professional Employees, AFL-CIO |
DC |
|
32 |
Economic Policy Institute |
DC |
|
33 |
FAIR -- Fairness & Accuracy In Reporting |
NY |
|
34 |
Future of Music Coalition |
DC |
|
35 |
GIDEON PRODUCTIONS (part of Writers Guild West filing) |
CA |
|
36 |
Global Resource Action Center for the Environment |
NY |
|
37 |
Granite Broadcasting Corporation |
VA |
|
38 |
Hodson Broadcasting |
CA |
|
39 |
Honolulu Community Media Council |
HI |
|
40 |
Information Policy Institute |
NY |
|
41 |
JAM Productions (Jerry Mickelson) |
DC/IL |
|
42 |
JOHN WELLS PRODUCTIONS (part of Writers Guild West filing) |
CA |
|
43 |
Journal inquirer |
CT |
|
44 |
Kennel Wood Broadcasting Co. Inc |
TX |
|
45 |
Long Island Coalition for Fair Broadcasting |
NY |
|
46 |
Los Angeles County Commission on Human Relations |
CA |
|
47 |
MBC Grand Broadcasting |
VA |
|
48 |
Media Access Project |
DC |
|
49 |
Media Alliance |
CA |
|
50 |
Media Democracy Legal Project |
CA |
|
51 |
Media Ownership Working Group |
DC |
|
52 |
Mediacom Communications Corporation |
MO/NY |
|
53 |
MEDIASCOPE (part of Writers Guild West filing) |
CA |
|
54 |
Minority Media and Telecommunications Council |
DC |
|
55 |
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF CHILD ADVOCATES (part of Children Now filing) |
CA |
|
56 |
NATIONAL INSTITUTE ON MEDIA AND THE FAMILY (part of Children Now filing) |
CA |
|
57 |
National Organization for Women |
DC |
|
58 |
NATIONAL PTA (part of Children Now filing) |
CA |
|
59 |
Nat'l Ass'n of Black Owned Broadcasters/Rainbow-PUSH Coalition |
DC |
|
60 |
Nat'l Ass'n of Hispanic Journalists |
DC |
|
61 |
Newspaper Guild/Communications Workers of America |
DC |
|
62 |
OH SHOOT PRODUCTIONS (part of Writers Guild West filing) |
CA |
|
63 |
Pappas Telecasting Co. (Peter Pappas) |
DC |
|
64 |
Philadelphia Lesbian and Gay Task Force |
DC |
|
65 |
PRODUCERS GUILD OF AMERICA (part of Writers Guild West filing) |
CA |
|
66 |
Project for Excellence in Journalism |
DC |
|
67 |
Prometheus Radio Project |
PA |
|
68 |
REC Networks |
AZ |
|
69 |
Reclaim the Media |
WA |
|
70 |
Representative David Price |
DC |
|
71 |
Representative Maurice Hinchey |
DC |
|
72 |
Richmond Free Press |
DC |
|
73 |
Rural Video Coalition |
DC |
|
74 |
Sand Key Massage Center |
DC |
|
75 |
Seattle Times (Frank Blethen) |
DC |
|
76 |
Senator Mike DeWine/Senator Herb Kohl |
DC |
|
77 |
SHUKOVSKY ENGLISH PRODUCTIONS (part of Writers Guild West filing) |
CA |
|
78 |
Sisters of St. Joseph |
DC |
|
79 |
Small Video Operators Serving Rural Areas |
DC |
|
80 |
Stop 26-Riverbend,Inc. |
OH |
|
81 |
To Your Health Inc |
DC |
|
82 |
TV-Turnoff Network |
DC |
|
83 |
UBU PRODUCTIONS (part of Writers Guild West filing) |
CA |
|
84 |
United Church of Christ |
DC |
|
85 |
United States Conference of Catholic Bishops |
DC |
|
86 |
UNITY: Journalists of Color |
VA |
|
87 |
Virginia Center for Public Press |
VA |
|
88 |
WEFT |
IL |
|
89 |
Women's Institute for Freedom of the Press |
DC |
|
90 |
Working Assets |
DC |
|
91 |
Writers' Guild of America |
DC |
|
92 |
Writers Guild of America, West |
CA |
|
93 |
WRMC Board of Directors |
VT |
|
94 |
Young Broadcasting Inc. |
DC |
|
95 |
ZGS Broadcasting (Wendy Thompson) |
DC |
Orgs/corps supporting some changes but not all:
|
1 |
Cox Enterprises (To-Quyen Truong, Dow Lohnes & Albertson) |
DC |
|
2 |
National Association of Broadcasters (Jeff Baumann)/NASA |
DC |
PDF of this FAQ
| Press Release | State
by state tally
home | manifesto
| resources | press
& news | events | FAQs | subscribe | contact
us
| Want to stay on top of music/tech issues? Subscribe to our monthly newsletter! Read the latest edition online here. Public Enemy Frontman, Production Team and Insiders Discuss Landmark Album FMC Files Reply Comments in FCC Localism Proceeding Wilco, Bright Eyes, Aimee Mann & more "Rock the Net" on Compilation CD Musicians Get the Hint About Health Insurance New York State Music Education Events Examine Crucial Issues Facing Artists New York State Music Education Events Examine Crucial Issues Facing Artists Philly Bands Rocking for Net Neutrality OK Go and Bonerama Rocked DC for New Orleans Musicians Upcoming Washington, DC show and benefit EP from OK Go & Bonerama Successful New Orleans Concerts Aid Big Easy Musicians FMC's Latest Fact Sheets Ann Chaitovitz Appointed Concerts for New Orleans Musicians Bring Artists Together FMC's Jenny Toomey Appointed Program Officer for Ford Foundation Seattle "Rocked the Net" Rock the Net: Campaign for Net Neutrality Rocks Seattle Future of Music Policy Summit to Tackle Critical Issues at the Intersection of Music, Law, Technology and Policy Registration Opens for FMC's Annual Policy Summit FMC files testimony with House Small Business Committee on CRB Webcasting Rates June 21, 2006 Indie-rock revolution, fueled by net neutrality Op-ed by FMC's Jenny Toomey and Michael Bracy June 13, 2006 Pearl Jam Donation To Help Musicians Help Themselves FMC's Michael Bracy Testifies in front
of House Judiciary Committee on "Digital Music Interoperability" |